Probiotics and Prebiotics: What the Evidence Shows

Gut health products are everywhere, from capsules to fizzy drinks. A few have good evidence for specific uses, but many promise far more than the research can support. Here is what each term means and what the evidence actually shows.

What the Words Mean

Probiotics are live bacteria or yeasts that can benefit health when taken in the right amount. They are found in some fermented foods and in supplements.

Prebiotics are types of fibre that feed the helpful bacteria already living in your gut.

Fibre is the part of plant foods your body cannot fully digest. Prebiotics are one kind of fibre, but there are many others, and all of them play a role in gut health.

Probiotics

Probiotics are strain-specific. A strain is a particular type within a bacterial species, a bit like a breed within a species of dog. Evidence for one strain does not apply to another, so a label promising billions of good bacteria tells you very little unless it names the strains and what they have been tested for.

There is reasonable evidence for:

  • Reducing the risk of diarrhoea while taking antibiotics, with specific strains such as Saccharomyces boulardii or Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG

  • Some people with IBS, although results vary and guidelines disagree. If you try one, give it up to 12 weeks and stop if nothing changes

The evidence is weak or missing for:

  • General gut health in people without symptoms

  • Weight loss

  • Claims about immunity, skin health, mood or energy

Most probiotic bacteria do not settle in the gut permanently. They tend to pass through, which is why any benefit usually fades once you stop taking them.

Prebiotics

Prebiotic fibres are found naturally in many everyday foods, including:

  • Onions, leeks, spring onions and garlic

  • Oats and barley

  • Beans and lentils of all kinds, including chickpeas

  • Slightly green bananas

  • Asparagus and artichokes

Getting prebiotics from food also gives you the other nutrients in those foods. Prebiotic supplements can cause gas and bloating, especially if you start with a large dose.

Fibre Comes First

Fibre is the single most useful dietary change for gut health, and most women do not get enough. The recommendation in Switzerland and the UK is 30 grams a day, yet most women eat about half of that. Simple ways to increase it:

  • Add beans or lentils to a meal three or four times a week

  • Choose wholegrain bread, oats, brown rice or wholewheat pasta over white versions

  • Aim for two portions of vegetables at lunch and dinner

  • Eat fruit with the skin on where you can

  • Add a small handful of nuts or seeds each day

Increase fibre gradually over a few weeks and drink enough water, so your gut has time to adjust.

Variety counts as well as quantity. A large study called the American Gut Project found that people who ate 30 or more different plant foods a week had a more varied gut microbiome than those who ate 10 or fewer. Herbs, spices, nuts and seeds all count. This type of study shows a link rather than proof, but it fits well with other research on fibre and gut health.

For most women, a varied, fibre-rich diet will do more for gut health than any product on the shelf, at a fraction of the cost. Probiotics can be useful in specific situations, ideally chosen with advice from a dietitian or doctor.

Previous
Previous

Gut Symptoms: When to See a Doctor

Next
Next

IBS in Women: Why Symptoms Change With Your Cycle